The Magistrates’ Association is pleased that the government has responded positively to some of our real concerns and proposals submitted in our response to the Green Paper. We support the principles of delivering sentences which contribute effectively to reducing re-offending.
We welcome proposals to:
- strengthen and extend the provision of community programmes;
- widen judicial discretion in dealing with breaches of community orders;
- extend the powers in the use of curfews and electronic monitoring;
- ensure community payback is more rigorous and effective with an emphasis on early starts and longer working hours and days;
- widen judicial discretion in imposing community programmes such as mental health treatment;
- develop greater transparency in sentencing, sentence delivery and reporting.
We appreciate that the proposal to create a clear national framework recognises the issues the Association raised over eighteen months ago in relation to the inconsistent and in appropriate imposition of out of court disposals. However we believe that extending the powers of the police to administer conditional cautions is trespassing on judicial discretion, although we support the wider use of educational programmes.
John Thornhill, Chairman of the Magistrates’ Association said, “We are disappointed that the government has not understood our arguments for maintaining the right to remand in custody as a bail option for every defendant. Whilst the ‘no real prospect test’ provides for a degree of discretion it requires a presumption as to sentence at a very early stage, which is not in the interests of justice.”
We appreciate that the proposal to repeal Section 154 of the 2003 Criminal Justice Act giving magistrates twelve months custody for a single offence is based on the principle that it is inextricably connected with the concept of custody plus which has never been implemented for financial reasons. However we have always believed that the extension of magistrates’ custodial powers would bring significant financial benefits by reducing delays and costs of proceedings in Crown Courts. We expect the Prime Minister to keep his pre – election promise to increase magistrates’ powers.
View Bill at Parliament website
View transcript of Commons debate